Billy’s Seafood Company

We've searched high and low for the best lobster rolls. This is hands down the best. The seafood chowder was amazing as was the crab cake. It's not the fastest but definitely the best. The wait staff was wonderful, and we visited with the owner while waiting. Don't miss this place or you will be sorry.

Highly recommended. Great food and atmosphere. Seated and greeted right away with a smile.

Well deserved position as one of the best sea food options we could find in our visit to St. John. Service was lacking a bit but I think it was bad timing - mid week mid day? The neighborhood is a bit sketchy. I've never been to a place with so many mental health needs on display.

I ordered the lobster dinner and the partner had the rolls. The appetizer was crab cakes. All around great flavour, good price, and we left feeling satiated.

We were greeted immediately with a smile. Seated as soon as available. We had the large lobster roll, ceviche, crab cakes, and chowder. Everything was so amazing, both presentations and a party to the palette. Succulent lobster, flavorful ceviche, dreamy chowder and the crab cakes were fabulous. Service was fantastic. A must go to in St. John's Bay.

De l’accueil à l’assiette et la note, un régal.
Les pâtes au pesto et le burgeur au crabe de la maison, de belle assiette très goûteuse et en quantité, un serveur super sympa qui s’est même risqué à parler français avec nous. Merci a lui c’était cool.
Une belle adresse à ne pas manquer

Fish was great, fries were unfortunately very heavily seasoned and far too plentiful which detracted from the "fish and chips" experience.

Lobster roll was delicious, but overpriced for a “large”. Everything else was kind of bland, and service was slow.

It was a long wait for food that was less than mediocre. The Cajun dish was dull and watery, and the chicken dish was flat tasting and dry. The waitress didn’t even ask why I left most of the dish behind. This restaurant promised way more than it delivered. Not recommended.

Drinks were great, service was good, atmosphere was cramped but inviting.

Seafood stew; the seafood was well cooked, rice was tender but the sauce to tie everything together was neither Cajun nor spicy. It was basically uncooked tomato puree.

Fish tacos; fish was cooked well, veg/fruit was in large chunks and way to over powering. Again this was way underseasoned.

Food was decent - their lobster roll in particular is delicious (one of the best I’ve ever had)! Unfortunately dishes were a bit overpriced and small in portion.

Service wise, while the staff was kind, I felt some things could be made more efficient. Many tables sat idle / empty with reservation times while we were seated, and food was sent out slowly. Waiters needed to prepare drinks on top of serving customers which created a bottleneck. Be prepared for a long wait time as a result (1-2 hours).

Good quality fresh food. Bring your wallet). Good seafood is not inexpensive.
Corey gave us great service. I'll come back again if I'm ever in st. John.

Great food in a central location. Too bad about the empty construction site in front of the patio.

We came to the restaurant with intentions of having a great seafood lunch but this turned out to be the worse time. First we waited to be seated for ever even though there was hardly anyone in the restaurant then. The host seated us and all we ever got was water 20 minutes and still had never seen a waiter or waitress finally we just walked out because no one ever came to our table terrible service

Was looking forward to a delicious seafood lunch. The restaurant was not busy and yet it took 10 minutes to be seated. After waiting 20 minutes to have our order taken we left without service. I cannot rate the food as we never got to taste anything. Thoroughly disappointed.

After waiting at the door for an extended time we were finally seated. The only thing we got to taste was the lemon water. No service was given in a 20minute wait. Restaurant only had 3 tables including our table and 1 outside Walked out and went to the food market were we given better service from a taco vendor than a highly rated restaurant. Boo to billys you can do better!

Waiter was hofell did not give are drinks right both wrong when you say 6 o.z it's not 9oz, glass of wine, and a I. P. A draft beer is not a Alexander's Keith's beer bottle!

After the failed first visit (the chowder was great but the lobster roll was too salty and chewy, and the dish my wife has was very bland, both the consistency and the flavor) we lowered our expectations, and went for simpler dishes. The fish and chips was top tier, among the best we had. Big portion size too, my daughter went for the two piece and brought home half the plate. Fish tacos were good too. And the Pesto Pasta was a great surprise. I'm not a fan of pasta, but it was just spot on. Scallops were good too.
We will be returning.

Avoid the seafood chowder. Thin milky broth. Very little seafood. Not worth $21 for a bowl