19 January 2024 5:22
I must express my utmost appreciation for the exceptional care provided by the manager during my recent dining experience. Late on a Thursday night, when most places might falter, the manager's attention to detail and commitment to customer satisfaction stood out. The heathy steak salad I ordered was a testament to the culinary excellence of this establishment – a perfect blend of flavors and quality ingredients. The dedication to maintaining high standards, even during off-hours, speaks volumes about the restaurant's commitment to excellence. I wholeheartedly recommend this spot and look forward to returning for more delightful meals that are truly worth the money invested. The superior quality and the manager's attentive service make it a destination I'll enthusiastically frequent.
28 April 2023 3:55
My wife and I came here on a whim for lunch, after shopping for tiles in the area. The rating was 4.2 which is pretty decent. I generally only frequent places with ratings of 4 or greater - and this is one of few places that I’ve gone to that was definitely overrated. The $18 sub was way over-priced ($12 would have been far more appropriate). The Caesar salad was a decent size, but was anything but a Caesar salad - the only thing it had in common with a Caesar salad was the lettuce and onion. The place was dirty - tables and chairs weren’t clean. No excuse for that especially since the sit down area wasn’t busy. The chairs are the ones you might keep in your garage if you run out of chairs for a card game - rusty and rickety. The manager then comes around to sweep the floor and while doing so is bodychecking you. If this wasn’t enough, the service was painfully slow - and I bet it’s because they are geared to large local takeout orders instead of walk-ins. I rate them 3, tops - actually 2, with an added bonus point because it’s my birthday and I’m in a generally good mood. Bubby needs to swing by and take a look at what’s going on because the current staff need a talking to.
14 April 2023 11:19
This was a munch! Yummers! Its like I always used to say, if there not kosher then they are a poser! Love this place authentic kosher food.will be back!
20 January 2023 2:29
Pleasant and quick service. Burger very overpriced for the mediocre quality. Onion rings were a great since kosher ones are usually diced onion. Large serving. Unfortunately they were barely warm and either overcooked or cooked in old oil. Overall, mediocre, overpriced, but glimmers of hope.
03 December 2022 23:16
A very generous three stars. No bagels, no bagels, no bagels! Despite my travelling a long way and a sign that says New York Bagels; no bagels! Staff didn’t really even react to the confused middle-aged man wandering around the restaurant looking for bagels; left without any interaction. All this said, the customers eating New York burgers (? !? !) appeared to be happy.
01 August 2022 0:19
Hard to see if your not paying attention but I'm glad I was.
This is a small dinner offering some unique food options at a fair price.
It's been open now for about a year and it's off to a good start.
If you like supporting small businesses rather than franchises then come on in and try this place.

I had the poppers. (chicken bites)
I enjoyed them they were cooked nicely and they were definitely fresh and good quality chicken breast.

The young gentleman at the counter was very friendly and helpful.
28 August 2021 12:42
Should have shared on their website that they are no longer serving bagels, for a place that includes bagels in its name. I walked 15 minutes in the cold rain to get here just to be told that. Customer service used to be amazing up until a couple weeks ago. Really disappointed.
21 July 2021 10:42
Usually I like them. I made a decent sized order today through uber. I paid delivery and service fees. The food came cold and stale. There were no sauces with the sushi or the french fries. The tuna melt had hardly any tuna or cheese. The pizza bagel was made with a small amount of sauce and cheese that covered only half of the bagel. I was very disappointed.
12 August 2020 18:35
I decided to try their colourful bagel with cream cheese and lox (Salmon, for those of you who don't know).
It was a bit pricey ($10.50, I believe), but if you are looking for quality you will find it here. You get what you pay for- here, that means one hell of a good time.
Also tried the red velvet cookie- very good!

Write a Review for Bubby’s New York Diner



Overall Rating: