Carmine's Pizzeria Italiano

Ordered 2 Lg pizza's. Cooked perfectly, always consistent and ready on time. Thank You Carmine's

Great pizza! Most places around here don't put enough sauce on their pizzas. Will definately be ordering from here again.

Tried the gluten free pizza last night and it was great! They took extra care to give the pizza enough time to fully rise and make gluten free taste good. We love a good neighborhood pizza joint and Carmine’s did not disappoint.

Not sure what I'm missing when I read these five star reviews. The pizza is 'meh' and the prices are not exactly a bargain. I've had worse, but on the flip side, I've had so much better.

This is definitely a great pizza place. Would recommend to anybody who wants a quick pizza on the go or just to sit and enjoy by the falls. Great assortment of options and toppings, and a low rising crust with a great crisp.

️
You can't buy Happiness; but you can buy delicious Pizza here, which eventually makes you Happy.

Our party food was a hit! Thanks to Carmine's. The 2 party trays were beautiful and tasty and my sister raved about her gluten free pie. The wings were cooked well done just as I ordered, Everyone enjoyed and asked where we ordered from. Thanks Carmine's

Carmine is easy to deal with and cares about his customers and products. Thank you for your support of our local fund raiser. Everyone loved the pizza!
Always support local business

The pizza and wings are the best in the Niagara Region. The staff is always friendly and polite and knows you on a first name basis. Won't go anywhere else.

100 percent the best pizza in town, had them all won’t waste my time any where else
Proper distribution of cup n char
Countless times I’ve ordered a medium and he upgrades to a large free.

First time ordering from there and they didn't disappoint, I ordered 2 party trays and they where delicious and a hit! Thank you for a wonderful pizza at a reasonable price!

Worst pizza ever. Ordered medium pizza/double pepperoni and double mushrooms. Was told ready in 25 mins for pickup. Arrived 30 mins later and was told pizza won't be ready for another 10 mins. REALLY then say pizza will be ready in 40 mins then.
Got home started to eat. Bottom of pizza was well done/top of pizza cooked and center of pizza was raw.the top of the dough where the ingredients lay was raw and doughy. Canned mushrooms instead of fresh. Threw it in the garbage where it belonged.
$23.00 for a garbage pizza. Do yourself a favor and go to a real pizza joint.there are lots in town but this isn't one of them.
0 stars but you have to put at least one star to post.

I’ve gone there twice trying to get a slice of pizza and they never have them. All I get is a sorry. Clearly, they don’t mind losing business.

Best pizza place in the Falls hands down I drive from Fort Erie just to get the pizza and wings here!

They forgot items on my tray and it was so bad. Even though this place is so close I could open my door and be there in seconds I would rather order from a place that would get my order right. And appreciate my business instead of the attitude I got from them.

Carmines never disappoints. Staff and owner are so friendly. I won't order from anywhere else!

I was very happy with our pizza last night and the service from I believe was the owner Carmine. We will be coming back in the coming weeks for this great pizza.

We used to love carmines and order all the time, we even ordered 20 pizzas from them for our stag and doe 6 years ago but everytime we try them again it gets worse and worse. Tonight we ordered a chicken Parm sub and an Italian cold cut sub. This is what the chicken Parm sub looked like. I paid $28 for these 2 subs, subway would have been better. I also asked for no tomato on the Italian sub and guess what, it had tomato. This place has gone down hill from what it used to be.

I am so saddened to have to move on from Carmines. We LOVED them, they have been our favourite but tonight was the 3rd chance we gave them and the last chance. Something has changed in the past 6 months with their pizza, sauce and wings. Also whoever is cutting the slices needs to do better, it was like 16 slices all different sizes. Carmines sorry to leave you, go back to the way things were.

Never disappointed, pizza is amazing, wings are fantastic (and when you ask for them saucy they do sauce them up)