Castle John's Newmarket
13 reviews 18025 Yonge St, Newmarket, ON +1 905-235-6646 www.castlejohns.com suggest an edit
04 December 2023 14:29
I had the fish and chips, best ever, and the homemade tartar sauce was amazing. Paul had a corn beef sandwich with fries and coleslaw, and his was absolutely fantastic, he said. Large servings! Our server Jessie was great. Thanks
This place is a must to dine at.
This place is a must to dine at.
19 November 2023 10:15
Great experience at Castle John's. Both Sheena and Jessie were excellent bartenders/servers. I will definitely be back.
10 November 2023 23:47
The food is good with a lot of variety. It is not a high-class restaurant, but it is good if you like watching sports while eating, or playing darts or pool.
08 November 2023 9:03
One of the best an absolutely delicious hamburgers. I have eaten in my entire life delicious flavorful, well seasons I forget the name of the hamburger that I got, but it was bacon with jalapeño fries were crispy. Service was good. The gentleman was attentive.
The only complaint I have were the seats sitting in the booth I felt I was always sitting at a 90° angle and not a lot of room. Other than that atmosphere was a good and the bar look like a good place to watch a game
The only complaint I have were the seats sitting in the booth I felt I was always sitting at a 90° angle and not a lot of room. Other than that atmosphere was a good and the bar look like a good place to watch a game
29 May 2023 23:42
It was a really great place for a quick bite to eat love the food service was exceptional, atmosphere was fun especially with the game on.
15 May 2023 6:48
Great place! Came down because they play the leaf game on the maaaaaasive tv. Food was amazing! Service was top notch! Will definitely be coming back
14 May 2023 22:18
Tonight, my husband and I received exceptional service from our server, Viki. She provided prompt, friendly service and you could tell that she cared about our experience. We are regular customers who enjoy the quality of food and the atmosphere. The staff are all outgoing and welcoming every time. The menu has a lot to offer; delicious food and great value. We would highly recommend this restaurant.
29 April 2023 9:43
It’s never as good as I think it’ll be. Had the Chicken Souvlaki Dinner. The rice was what I can only say was horrid. Wet, funny mess & just peas & carrots in it. Yuck! Chicken Souvlaki was so-so, not particularly tasty. At least the Greek salad was fabulous. I could of just had that & left happy. Probably should of!
Our server seemed a bit off & kept making mistakes, maybe his 1st night? 1 person ordered ribs, they came with chicken wings he didn’t order. 1 ordered chicken Parmesan, I’ve never seen it layered with cheddar cheese before, not a great idea & very over cooked. Waiter brought 4 small plates with 3 forks, 2 knives & 2 serviettes. There were 3 of us & all needed knives & serviettes, & for ribs seriously you need at least 2. Been twice, not really impressed. Would be a good sports bar to be at for game night, but it was a surprise to us when they pushed the volume way up half way through our dinner. If we go back it’ll probably be at lunch time & see if that works out better.
Our server seemed a bit off & kept making mistakes, maybe his 1st night? 1 person ordered ribs, they came with chicken wings he didn’t order. 1 ordered chicken Parmesan, I’ve never seen it layered with cheddar cheese before, not a great idea & very over cooked. Waiter brought 4 small plates with 3 forks, 2 knives & 2 serviettes. There were 3 of us & all needed knives & serviettes, & for ribs seriously you need at least 2. Been twice, not really impressed. Would be a good sports bar to be at for game night, but it was a surprise to us when they pushed the volume way up half way through our dinner. If we go back it’ll probably be at lunch time & see if that works out better.
21 April 2023 15:54
This is our second time here and once again we were amazed! We were too early for the wing and rib combo special but the food we ordered was fantastic! The ribs are sooooo good! I love going to Rib fests and Castle Johns are way better!
09 April 2023 8:51
Horrible service.
Wife and I ordered apps and mains. Wife got her app and main and finished before I received anything. Apparently the waiter didn’t punch mine in. Funny thing is he wrote the order down when he took it. How do you forget to punch it in when you wrote it down!
We just ended up leaving. Not even busy. The waiter was too busy socializing i guess!
Wife and I ordered apps and mains. Wife got her app and main and finished before I received anything. Apparently the waiter didn’t punch mine in. Funny thing is he wrote the order down when he took it. How do you forget to punch it in when you wrote it down!
We just ended up leaving. Not even busy. The waiter was too busy socializing i guess!
30 March 2023 21:02
Really enjoyed this newer chain of roadhouse type food and drinks restaurant, this is the 3rd one I have visited, good-sized portions, great service and reasonable prices.
27 March 2023 6:36
AN AMAZING EXPERIENCE! EVEN THOUGH THEY WERE VERY BUSY, BARTENDER MANAGER SHEENA (WASNT EVEN SCHEDULED TO WORK) LOOKED AFTER OUR TABLE! WE REALLY APPRECIATED THE OUTSTANDING SERVICE! FOOD WAS FANTASTIC AND THE ENVIRONMENT JUST WOW! WE WILL DEFINITELY BE BACK!
ALSO SHOUT OUT TO AN INCREDIBLE PERFORMANCE BY THE DEVEREAUX DOLLS & CARMEN DELRAE!
ALSO SHOUT OUT TO AN INCREDIBLE PERFORMANCE BY THE DEVEREAUX DOLLS & CARMEN DELRAE!
17 February 2023 1:03
We ordered through Uber Eats. The food arrived fairly quickly but wasn’t great. My partner got fish tacos which he described as meh. I got chicken wings and they were so dry and salty they were almost inedible. We won’t be ordering again.