Goodfella's Pizzeria

Was super excited to try the mozzarella stick and bacon pizza, but was very dissapointed. It tasted okay but did not have extra cheese as it advertised. Also, the pizza was not fresh. It tasted as though it had been made earlier in the day and re heated. Was not hot on arrival and was barely even warm. Not worth the price at all. Do not recommend. Better off getting Domino's stuffed cheesy bread and adding mozzarella sticks to it and WAY cheaper.

Our family of 4 adults ordered a Margherita pizza, and a pizza with pepperoni and pineapple. It was absolutely delicious! This will be our go-to place from now on.

The pizza is probably by far the worst I have ever had. The staff last night however was nice to deal with. I would never give this store my money again.

Very good pizza, friendly staff, and fairly priced. My family orders from here all the time.

The food is great, prices are very fair, and the staff are very friendly and helpful. Overall a great experience.

The Pizza was very good. I find almost every Pizza place I have gone to the chicken wings are a bit small. So I would say they were tasty and average size.we will order here again.

Pizza was delicious, the new owners are killing it, they even threw in a free cheese bread. Definitely our new go to spot. Delivery driver was very friendly too!

Small place but big on taste and value. Great selection of toppings and dishes. I've never had a pizza so big. The past was cooked perfectly with just the right amount of sauce.

Ordered a double cheese pizza and a sun-dried tomato and feta pizza.ingredients are so fresh, sauce is amazing and crust is perfect!

Where do I start? We ordered what we thought would be standard pizza, panzo and pasta. But mama Mia! The panzos were absolutely huge and delicious. The pizza my kids LOVEDDD. The pasta my mother in law loved. We even got a free cheesy bread and even that blew out our expectations.

Quality of food is easily 5️
Portion Size for price 5️
Taste 5️
Overall 5️ experience.

Such a great place, do not hesitate to sink your teeth into some Goodfellas Pizzeria!

The pizza was so good. Perfect sauce, lots of cheese, perfect amount of toppings, easy ordering online. We will definitely order again.

I got 2 slices of Pepperoni Pizza. The cheese was good and the slices were fresh, very high quality. The attendant was also very nice thank you for the pizza

Absolutely amazing every time. We had the pasta for the first time and wow. Portion was great and amazing homemade taste.

Always the same story, whenever I come here to pick up an order, I need to wait 15-20mins. Even they claim that management has been changed and they are trying to improve their service but definitely they can not manage orders. I do not think this business is rocket science just simple cooking pizza.

Pizza was great and lots of toppings. The deep fried pickles were a good size and tasted great.

Owner is super nice! Had a great conversation with him while waiting for my pizza. Affordable too!

EDIT - this review is no longer relevant. The restaurant has changed owners and the pizza is now absolute trash. Do not bother with this dive.

Goodfellas has become my family's go-to when it comes to ordering up food for a pizza night. The quality is always consistent. We've only ever had the pizza here (I think pasta and bread sides are offered). We simply don't order from any other pizza place because there is no point, this place is the best.

This place used to be absolutely amazing. My husband and I have ordered twice since the change in ownership and it was disappointing each time. The crust is doughey, the cheese has the texture of it being melted in the microwave and the toppings are of lower quality. It's a real bummer, to be honest.

I love a good pizza that doesn't skimp out on the toppings. I also love a basic pizza with minimal toppings. I'm a paradox in that sense. Anyways, this spot has some of the most loaded pie's i've ever had. Great portions to cost ratio. Highly recommend.