Maestro's Pizzeria

Certainly! Here's a 5-star review for a pizza place:

I recently had the pleasure of trying the pizza at Maestro's Pizzeria, and I must say, it was an absolutely fantastic experience from start to finish!

The toppings were incredibly fresh and flavorful. The cheese was generous and melted to perfection, giving the pizza that irresistible gooeyness we all crave.

Not only was the pizza amazing, but the service was top-notch. The staff was friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about their menu. The ambiance was cozy and inviting, making my dining experience even more enjoyable.

I am so bummed. I haven't been here in years but I remembered it being my absolute favorite place for pizza. So of course now that im back in the area i had to order. Got a cheese and pep party tray tonight. What a disappointment. What happened? Dough is flat and tough to chew. Sauce is abnormally acidic and spicy. Cheese is like rubber. I almost never leave bad reviews but I'm in shock right now.
New owners or something?

Google says they are open at 10am. Placed an order online and walked over there, door locked. Call the number listed, no answer. Brutal.

I had an amazing experience with one of the best pizzas in St. Catharines. Staff is always friendly and pizzas taste are to die for! 100% recommended

I stopped at maestros for a tray because it was Halloween and needed something quick, I hadn’t eaten there in a while since it was sold to new owners but figured give it a try.

Unfortunately the quality went down hill, cheese barely cooked and very soft and doughy. The price is very reasonable so hopefully it was just a busy day and they pulled the pizza out too soon.

Best pizza I ever had in my life, Perfect crust with great portion of toppings.
I will be defiantly back in town Specially to have this from now.

I recently had an unfortunate experience at Maestro's Pizzeria and I cannot recommend it. The pizza, which I suspect used frozen pizza crust, was the worst I have ever had, and I am pretty sure we got food poisoning from it. The facilities did not seem clean, which was concerning. Additionally, the prices were quite high for the quality of the food. There was a significant delay in pick-up time; the pizza was not ready when we arrived. It seems like the previous owner made a mistake by selling this place. The pizza had a strange taste, and the little sauce on it was terrible. The wings were incredibly dry, not editable at all. To top it off, I discovered that the owner keeps all the tips and does not share them with the hardworking employees who deserve them. Overall, my experience at Maestro's Pizzeria was disappointing and I would not recommend it.

Pizza was amazing, the staff were super friendly, the old tables I think are from Julius Pizza restaurant. We order here most of the time because we haven't had a bad pizza yet.

Placed a big order for the family. Nobody had any complaints everything exceeded expectations. Great food, great service, fair prices.

Great quality pizza and when you ask for extra saucy wings, you get extra saucy wings. Parking for pickup is a nightmare, be advised. Asked for well done pizza, came out perfect. Top tier.

First time customers tonight. Saw adds on Instagram. I have never had such a pretty pizza! Lots of care went into making sure each slice had the perfect ratio of toppings! They made our wings extra crispy as requested, and the seasoning was perfect. Very unique pizza experience. I can’t wait to try more of the menu. I don’t normally leave reviews, but this was worth it.

The pizza was very good with nice choices. We wanted to dine in with my wife and two little kids; however, dining in was not satisfactory due to the lighting quality, the arrangement of the tables and the presence of a drunk guy next to us who kept on looking at my kids and talking to them. We had to leave the place and take the food with us to the hotel.

When ownership changed I was worried the quality would change with it. Happy to say I was wrong. It's still the same fantastic food as always. Generous toppings, good size wings, and always service with a smile. Very highly recommend

Staff are always friendly and amazing. Pizza wings and subs are incredible. Pizza has the right amount of grease. Steak subs are cooked perfectly. Free WiFi. Free Parking. No credit card surcharge.

Changed owners and the specials are not so great anymore. The recipes may be the same but the specials are gone

Amazing pizza, super nice staff. Very fresh, fulllll of toppings! We tried the Works Pizza and loved it. Would highly recommend it

The staff was great and very friendly. The food was superb. I will definitely be back as it's the best pizza place in town