North of Brooklyn Pizzeria

Definitely a must try pizza! This is your ideal pizzeria if you are into very thin crusted pizzas with a couple toppings!

I ordered the killer bee pizza with the garlic dipping sauce. The pizza was great with a good balance of toppings to sauce. The hot honey on this pizza really made it for me combined with the creamy garlic dipping sauce. Will definitely be back to try out the other pie’s.

Important to note that you can’t order slices here and have to purchase a full pie.
Also no seating area at this location.

1/3 of our order didn't come. Staff refused to help and were rude on the phone. Told us we had to come and pick it up.

There is a fatty girl, her behavior is very bad and unprofessional. Also she doesn’t follow hygiene.

Got a couple of pizzas and each one of them tasted so good especially pepperoni and killer bee. A must try pizzeria if you haven't' yet.

Got the killer bee and special meatie pie. Both tasted great, the killer bee was a bit misshapen but still good. Service was amazing with a short wait time.

I strolled past The Village location and found myself craving pizza, so I decided to step inside. It was a bit disappointing that they didn't offer pizza by the slice, as I was hoping to sample a variety, but I ended up ordering a large pepperoni pizza.

The service was impressively speedy and the staff were exceptionally friendly. The pizza itself exceeded my expectations and I found it to be quite enjoyable. What's more, the pricing seemed quite reasonable given the location. Unlike the generic chain or franchise pizza you often encounter elsewhere, this was a genuine treat. I highly recommend stopping by for a delicious pizza experience.

Got the vodka pizza. It was pretty bomb! Except the crust on the pizza was 4 inches and naked, maybe drizzle some oil on there some sesame seeds honey I don’t care what you do just dress it up if you’re gonna make a 4 inch crust. The pizza went from a large to a small real quick. And y’all gotta step up the game with your dipping sauces.

No seating, can't understand what the cashier is saying and overpriced but the pizza is solid.

Be aware that there (at least when I was visiting) is no interior seating. Ordered the Killer Bee, a good pizza. Having honey on a spicy pizza was a good addition, as the flavours balanced out quite nicely.

Had the NY-style cheese pizza, was an excellent thin-crust pizza and definitely worth the try if you live near the pizzeria but not something i’d travel for.

Got pizza for delivery, was super happy with the taste and quality - be prepared because the pizza is on the thinner side it isn’t as filling as you’d expect

Best pizza in the CITY! And I know my pizza! We always get the mushroom and truffle and the NY cheese. Last night we tried the spinach one with pesto and sun dried tomatoes and it was a dream. Yum yum yum! Garlic dip is great too!

It’s decent, but it’s pricey and there are better options. I didn’t find it very memorable and I wasn’t blown away.

North of Brooklyn Pizzeria takes their pizza very seriously!

No doubt, they take their craft very seriously from the making of the fresh dough to the minuscule details of the fresh ingredients!

Nothing beats a classic Brooklyn Style Pepperoni Pizza which is a nice balance of spice and texture with the oozing cheese gently wrapping all the flavors together!

Had the
Margarita 10/10
NY Cheese 9/10
Truffle Shuffle 7/10. (Taste preference)

The crust was amazing and cheese was great quality. You could really tell that they use high quality ingredients. Def will have again if I’m in the area.

The pizza is incredible but we were only told that our pizza is missing cheese because the vegan cheese was running out. There was no heads-up or any compensation offered. It wasn’t the best to feeling having to accept a different product than what we ordered and having to pay the full amount.

Edit: The owner made a very generous offer of offering us new pies in response to the review below. I'm very happy to state that they were, as good if not better than the ones at Queen's. I am more impressed by how much North of Brooklyn cares for it's customers. I'll continue to tell ppl how they're one of the best pizzas in town. (If not the best:)

The one at Queen's is one of our favorite spots for a pizza in the city, very surprised that there can be such a difference in quality over here. We took away a truffle shuffle and vodka verde, both tested favs of ours, but very underwhelming. Dough was dry, like rubber in parts, the toppings and flavor non existent, repent picking up 2 large pies. Wouldn't go back and would recommend to just go to the one on Queen's.

Order was ready in time for takeaway so that was good so 2 stars. None for the food itself which was $29 a pie, wish I could've spent that elsewhere.

Ordered a pizza via delivery from the restaurant and it arrived like this. Not sure where the problem occurred (delivery or restaurant) but definitely disappointing.

Ordered a large pep for delivery was still very fresh and hot and arrived very quickly. Very tasty pizza and garlic sauce, no complaints - little bit pricey 30$ for one pizza but seems to be the norm

The best takeaway pizza in Toronto. Love the taste of most of the pizzas on the menu, especially “Special - Soppressata Hot Honey”.

Worst pizza experience - waited over an hour for delivery, the food was cold and they didn’t even bother to slice the pizza!

The green out pizza was good but very greasy and oily, and a little on the sweet side. The Margherita pizza tasted like nothing, and somehow had a burnt aftertaste. The garlic knots were only cooked on the outside and were very hard to chew. 2/3 were misses unfortunately.

Both times I tried to place an order on Uber Eats, they shut down ordering on the platform right at that moment. Not going to bother trying anymore,

I wish there had been more patio seating but they can't help how busy the area is! Great atmosphere.

Best pizzas ever had
Amazing staff
Crust is well cooked and a bit crunchy and ingredients are always fresh
You wont feel heavy after pizza
Love that
Highly recommended

Was so excited to try this place, visiting Toronto for a few days and after hearing rave reviews I had high hopes but $50 for a soggy, floppy somehow horribly chewy pizza and the worst “garlic” knots (comparable to eating a cold grease soaked rubber ball) I’ve ever had I’m just disappointed. I don’t know if it was just an off day or this location but I will never be coming back. Not to mention they had all of their dough out in the open in the front of the restaurant just sitting out

Considering its not a Brick Oven Pizza, it still manages to be a top quality pizza in all of GTA

Killer Bee is bomb! Satisfies the sweet and salty cravings. The 14" was enough for 2 ppl. For walk-in, pizza can be ready within 10-15 mins.

Went here yesterday for lunch. Glorified Little Caesars tasting pizza. Greasy (not a oily in a good way).

I could live with the higher price and holier-than-thou attitude from the staff if the pizza was good but come on. Forget about it.

Im sure they payed barstool for their “#1 pizza in toronto” review. I literally lost respect for Barstool and Portnoy because of this pizza.

Save your time and money. Go somewhere else. Id rather eat Dominos.

It's alright. Other than the dip none of the ingredients really packed much flavour. Really lacked in toppings - it's never a good sign when you have to add your own toppings at home.

It definitely doesn't live up to the hype and was probably one of the saddest looking pizzas I've ordered.

I'd eat it again if someone gave it to me, but at this pricepoint there are better premium pizza places.

Taste good but a bit pricy. Price is around $20-25 pre tax per pie. Meat lovers make sure you go for Pepperoni, Kale&Bacon, Killer bee (Calabrese sausage), Halifax donair (ground beef). I have Truffle Shuffle (mushroom), and it was great. Only sell whole pie instead of slices.

I've been here twice so far, both times got the NYC Cheese pizza. The place is small - not really meant for eating in. Got a takeout pie and ate it 10 minutes after picking it up. Super thin crust, with great spotted undercarriage. No flop. The crust is light and fluffy with a crunchy exterior. Cheese and sauce tasted good to me as well. This pizza is super crushable and satisfying. If they keep up this consistency, I will definitely keep coming back. My favorite pizza in the city right now.

They see as they are cutting pizzas if their oven temperature was off, but they don't care. The quality deteriorated each time over a period of months, although the oven temperature is a simple adjustment if they bothered to pay any attention. The last time we were there the pizza was absolutely burned black through all the way around, and yet it was raw in the middle. I do not mean New York style with a little char which I like; I mean the outer part BURNED THROUGH all the way around so our teeth could not manage it, while the dough in the middle was RAW GOOP. We used to always eat-in and we like our music loud and adventurous, but they starting blaring the volume beyond excruciating, and it became only ever 1 kind of music all about the F word and the N word. So we started getting take-out but even that didn't work because the pizza went down in quality each and every time worse and worse. The last time we couldn't get it down and I threw it out. It was gross.

I was told from a friend to go try Brooklyn Pizzeria and that I wouldn't regret it. And I sure didn't!
Im staying at a hotel on the waterfront. Took me 40min to walk in the heat and I would do it again.

I had thr NYcheese. Perfect crisp, perfect crust. Great flavors. Ate a whole medium sitting in some shade outside. I will definitely come again on my next trip to Toronto.

I wish there was good pizza like this in Montreal. Unfortunately its all the same doughy disaster that taste identical.

One of the best pizza places in Toronto! You can taste how fresh everything is, plus loved the thin crust and simple but delicious ingredients in perfect combination with each other. I recommend picking up to eat it when it’s hot and right out of the oven.

Note: They don’t sell slices, just full pizzas.

Pretty good pizza for decent prices considering the portions. We ordered pepperoni, cheese and the truffle one and honestly the truffle was the favourite! I recommend also getting the white dipping sauce for the pizza as it was a nice touch. All in all, pretty good pizza with convenient locations around the city.

Just ordered a cheese pizza large well done.it wasn't even cooked normal.that was extremely disappointing.

The food is amazing. The whole store is a treasure place in downtown region. The killer bee is the best in my flavor preference.

Best pizza in Toronto. They don't sell slices but the full pizza is 100% worth it. Pick it up and eat it fresh out of the oven if you can

Just ordered the truffle shuffle pizza and garlic knots from Uber Eats. There was absolutely no truffle flavour at all. Having had this before, it did not taste as it should. Similar to another review, I also noticed a name scribbled out on my box, guessing that “Julie” had maybe asked for the truffle to be left off. Very disappointing considering the crust and rest of toppings were good.
Garlic knots were cold, dense and not enjoyable at all. Not the delivery driver’s fault as the pizza was still warm. Would not order again.

I had order a large truffle shuffle pizza and an order of garlic knots. The pizza was enormous and toppings were great, the only thing was the sauce was a little bland. The garlic knots were a little overcooked making it tough but still enjoyable.

I was visiting in Toronto for the weekend, and after a long day of running around the city I wanted a good pizza - got the pepperoni with bacon and the sesame crust, it was so tasty!

I’m gonna steal that trick on my pizzas from now on!

100% recommend

I love the pizzas at NOB, but I ordered a cheese pizza after fasting for Ramadan and was delivered a pizza with pork on it, and it was cold and left in my condo lobby. When I called the person at customer service said they can only provide a partial refund. I’m so upset that on a holiday, I accidentally ate pork. I have a baby and all my lights were off because he’s sleeping. I can not recommend NOB when this is what happens.