Paezano's Pizza & Marketplace

This was my first time having pizza from Paezanos, and all I can say is Wow!
Without a doubt this was best pizza I’ve had in years and is without a doubt the best pizza you’ll find in Barrie.
The flavour was outstanding! The lightness of the crust was incredible.
Paezanos will be my go to from now on!
Quality and taste was top notch! Service was amazing! Was made to feel like family when I walked in.

I called the order in, but Will picked it up.

First time ordering pizza. It ranks one of the worst pizzas I have ever had. I was very specific in what I wanted. It was like they took a small dough, and stretched it into a large. It was so thin, I had to rip a bite off. I ordered 5 cheese, double cheese. I got so little cheese, you could hardly see it. It was greasy. There were bubbles at the crust edge. The piece I ate, had a huge bubble with nothing on it. I usually order from Papa Johns, and when I ask for cheese, I get a lot. I paid $49+ for two people. That is a whole lot of wasted cash. I ate one more piece just now, the following day, and put my own cheese on it. The crust was so hard, I could have pulled my teeth out, pulling on it. I ripped it off. The rest has mlzbeen thrown out. Even the man who lives, in a room here, did not want it. You want good pizza, with a lot of cheese then it is Papa Johns, you will get it. So dissappointed. I am going back to Papa Johns. You want cheese, you will get it there.

Finally tried Paezano's after many recommendations. All u can say is WOW! Pizza had amazing flavour. Can't believe it took this long to try it out. While waiting had a nice chat with the owner. Fantastic guy! Always try to support the small business in town. If you haven't tried it, don't wait like I did. You will be glad you did! Even tho it's a bit out of my way, it will most certainly become our go to place for pizza! Thank you for the delicious experience

Nice place going here for years.a typical mom and pop place not like a chain pizza shop
That have moved twice while in the same plaza. Now due to L&T disputes they are moving. Better for me as I can walk to the new location as opposed to driving.
Still a fantastic place. Good old mom&pop food. No big box cardboard tasting pizzas.

Super authentic Italian! Market inside restaurant and cool art. Friendly service. Prices are a bit high on the gelato. Everything is made fresh. Veal sandwich is delicious! Small Panzerotti is loaded and great size! Would go back.

We walked in for a slice today and we’re blown away. We found the prices to be incredibly reasonable, the staff to be friendly and the food to be absolutely delicious! 10/10 would recommend. Their menu offers lots of great options (variety of veggie and meat options). Multiple sides, dips, and beverage options as well. The sauce to cheese to topping ratio was perfect. It left us feeling full but not bloated or weighed down like most “fast food” pizzas. We are already looking forward to our next visit.

Ordered the pepperoni and chicken bruschetta pizzas from Paezanos last week. Such a cute pizza shop with a large variety! Pizzas were delicious, staff was lovely and a short wait.

Highly recommend

This place has the best Italian pastries, select products from Italy and a great deli meat selection! The pizza is amazing and the staff are always so welcoming and friendly. This place has been my favourite pizza place for the past decade!

Great pizza place and even greater people. Always a quality authentic pizza that doesn’t lack in flavour. They also have some of the best rice balls in the area!

Pizza and cheese bread were amazing. Best dough/crust I’ve had since growing up in Little Italy in Toronto. Killed it.

However, the fettuccine I ordered was just not up to par. The sauce was rosé and tasted like cheese sauce? Portion was small, and the few pieces of chicken for the extra cost were definitely not it. Disappointing there, but thoroughly enjoyed the pizza.
My husband even ordered a second one.

Their pizza is the best, and their gelato is out of this world! 10 out of 10, would recommend

Pizza wasn't even worth it like other times. I ordered a 4 topping pizza and rice balls. When I called to complain as the toppings were scarce especially the bacon, John confirmed they had put on 3 ounces of bacon measured in a cup. Which they obviously didnt and then proceeded to say okay? And didn't address the complaint. I was mad and hung up but constumer satisfaction should matter to a business like this. Maybe offer to remake the pizza. I was very disappointed with my pizza considering the cost. Not like other times I ordered it was great!

Gotta be one of the worst veal sandwiches I’ve ever had! I ended up tossing it which I’ve NEVER done before. I don’t get it … had a weird taste to it like as if it was frozen and defrosted or something. 100% not fresh cook to order. My first and last time going here unfortunately. I gotta stick to California's or the new place in south end for veal.the pizza did look good in the hot table area but don’t go for the sandwich!

Best pizza in Barrie. The pizza was unreal. Real Italian pizza made right here close to home. The family are incredible. Gotta check their pastas, all so delicious and unreal! Trust me. You gotta check them out!
And yes they have Gelato!

Dudes working there seemed pretty cool! Just went there a few minutes ago and got some pizza with feta and chicken they had and it is great! I’ll definitely be back!

Best pizza place in barrie! My families go to. The food & the people are just amazing!

I have travelled here from Toronto to pickup PAEZANO’S delicious pizza. Finally today had the Gelato and WOW absolutely amazing. Congrats

BEST GELATO PAEZANO’S Barrie. Must try it’s so delicious. Strawberry Banana Lemon Tiramisu’ and so many flavours to choose. Pizza also so amazing.

This was the first time my husband and I ordered from this place and I wish I could give it a better review. The pizza itself is good, it's not the best pizza I've had but it's a solid choice. The crust is nice and thin and tasted pretty good. Where it went downhill is the cauliflower bites, first it was missing the spicy mayo which wasn't the end of the world (I made my own at home) but the cauliflower was only described as disgusting.the batter that covered the cauliflower was half raw and soaked in oil, it left a chalky feeling in your mouth. I tried eating them but could only eat about 3 of them. It was a disappointment because I love good cauliflower bites and were looking forward to them. I don't want to say this will be my last time ordering from here but it was definitely a disappointing first experience.

Oh my goodnesssss! AMAZING! Tried their panzo last night and I won't be getting a panzo from anywhere else now! We probably could have went with smalls instead of larges, we didn't realize how big it was but the left overs for lunch today were so good! The service was absolutely amazing too, from the phone call placing our order to picking up to us forgetting our marinara and them making sure we got it. We already can't wait to go back!

Ordered from here for the first time tonight! We had pizza, ceaser salad and cannolis! Every thing was delicious 10/10 would recommend

I come from up north and I grew up eating pizza being Albanian you can't go wrong with these guys

Only issue is I live to far away! This is my new stop on route home from the cottage every time! Very good pizza, and a great feel and vibe being family owned. Highly recommend this place.

Pizza is a solid 15/5.delicious fresh toppings on amazing sauce and bread, thiss is my favorite pizza spot

Being from a small northern Ontario town that is mostly Italian it was hard to find authentic Italian food.well come on out to Paezanos Pizza.you won't be disappointed.don't forget to try the homemade sausage as well!

Awesome place to get pizza. A great selection of pizza, panzerotti, wings, salad e.t. C. Pizza is simply delicious, the staff is really friendly and they have unusual treats and snacks in store too. Highly recommended!

Best pizza in Ontario if not the entire country. Phenomenal staff! You HAVE TO try this place. I went here for the first time a month ago and I've been back multiple times a week. I've never left a review for anyone before. This place is worth it. 10/10