Pizza Nostra

I would go again…. If I was in the area.
I came here because I saw “Dave’s” pizza review. First time I went I guess the owner was on vacation because they were closed for the week… i’m cool with that. We all need a break. 2nd time I ordered before and went with a basic large pepperoni. It was good! You can taste the love the guy has in his pizza. Overall, I found the cheese good but not great and the sauce a little thick/strong tasting but it was definitely better than good. I wont go out of my way to go back (wish it was that good to crave) but if in the area, I’d grab a slice for sure.

This local pizza shop is a hidden gem and undoubtedly the best pizza I've ever tasted, and I've tried pizza all across the province. The quality and flavor of their pizzas are unparalleled. The crust is perfectly crispy, the toppings are fresh, and the sauce is just the right balance of tangy and savory. Every bite is a burst of deliciousness!

If you're a pizza enthusiast, you absolutely have to try this place. It's worth the visit.

We try many restaurants in the hopes to really find those specials ones. From New York, to new Heaven to Italy, I've had the pleasure to try some of the best pizzas available, so I can say with confidence that pizza Nostra ranks right up there with the best of them. To be able to isolate yourself as the best in a catagory as large as pizza is a true accomplishment. To say I was taken back from the spectacularness of this pizza is an understatement. So thin, so crispy and clearly made with daily fresh ingredients that can only create such a phenomenal pie. Even though this is not a New Heaven style, as far as quality and amazingness goes, I put this pizza in the ranks of Pepes and Sally's. As far as any pizza in Toronto, we are talking about the #1 pizza here people. If you don't like it, my guess is your more of a pizza pizza kind of person and we'll that's just a shame. Aside from the amazing food, the owners are a gem. They are true pizza people and a rare bread this day and age. It is with great enthusiasm that I highly recommend trying pizza Nostra if you want to experience what truly the best American Italian style pizza embodies.

New York style pizza. We got takeout.

Very fresh and high quality ingredients, but it's definitely expensive for the amount of food, and would be best enjoyed fresh - our pizza was not crunchy at all

The 14 inch is good for 1-2 people only since it's pretty thin, so order more than what you think

Called to order 2 pizzas at 5pm and was told my order wouldn't be ready till after 8pm. When asked her why she said they had a big order. Are you kidding me? So no other order because you have a big order? That is awful service, why stay open then to the public? Will never order from them again? They have lost a customer. Do better Pizza Nostra.

We decided to drop in and order a pizza and when we were told it was a one hour wait it did not phase us. Good things come to those that wait and when a place is busy it is typically a good sign. Well unfortunately the wait was not worth it. We are Hawaiian pizza connoisseurs. It was dried out and tasted like cardboard. I’m disappointed because I was really hoping to find a good quality pizza here and it Did not live up to the reviews that we read. But then again, maybe it was just an off night Or they just don’t know how to make a Hawaiian pizza.

Stopped by as a result of Dave Portnoy’s review and it was better than I possibly could have expected. Customer service was great and food ofc was equally incredible.

Honestly, the best pizza ever. Love the thin crust and taste of the dough. Best pizza in the GTA hands down!

Davey was right. Drove 40km for this and was so worth it. Got the cheese and the Canadian.

I had pizzas in all kind of restaurants and fast food places and this is Easly the best best best pizza I ever had.

The Canadian is top tier, best pizza i've ever had by a long shot.their house-made garlic is also the best I've ever had

Ordered the Firenze and was extremely impressed. You can tell a lot of thought went into the pizza, the flavors all come together - oregano, parmesan, basil.

This is the best pizza we have ever had in Toronto. My wife and I loved it. We did have another favourite (Fresca Pizza) downtown at Spadina and College but this takes 1st place.

The pizza was fresh, the tomatoes sauce and cheese was excellent. You can tell they put a lot of love in what they do. You can taste the freshness and ingredients.

It is also thin crust and thin pizza which makes it nice and crispy and light. I could easily eat a small pie on my own but shared it with my wife. The owner was very accommodating and nice as well.great staff and very welcoming.

Great stuff, worth the drive even if it was an hour. I can't wait to go back.

Dough and toppings are amazing. Definitely worth a try. Pizza doesn't cause you to bloat so that's a plus. Sauces seal the deal, just remember to order ahead for weekend as wait time upto 2 hrs at times.

Ordered 16” thin crust cheese pizza. Best pizza I’ve ever had. Great crunch on the crust. Amazing flavour. Worth driving to.

Absolutely amazing pizza place, the crust is perfectly crunchy, the sausce is delicious and has a hint of sweetness to it which makes it even better. The Margherita pizza is my favourite I’ve had in the city and would recommend to anyone.

Can't say enough great things about Pizza Nostra. From the ownership, the staff, the quality of the food.simply magnificent! Came from Georgetown area based on the great reviews and I will be going back!

Really tasty pizza. The sauce is incredible, cheese was really good too. Not too much, not too little.
I would have liked a tiny bit more crunch/firmness in the crust under the cheese, but what I had was better than it being too crispy.

My only complaint was that it was expensive - $33.50 for a large (16” and two cans of Coke) I guess that’s the Portnoy effect?

Definitely recommend nonetheless

I have now been here twice in 2 days. First time we ordered the Marco Special and was blown away by the quality of the pizza. The sauce, pepperoni and crust were all delicious. The creamy garlic sauce was garlicky but not over powering.
Next day we go the Peapack and again, delicious but this time we tried the hot Italian oil and it was just enough spiciness for me.
Would galdy recommend the pizza here, all the pizzas

Been coming here for about 5-6 years now, and I am just so glad to see this amazing family business get the love it deserves and more.

The pizza is always top notch, crispy light dough with tangy tomato sauce and very fresh ingredients. Before the pandemic they made an INSANELY good cheesesteak sandwich + eggplant parm sandwich (please bring it back <3)

I cannot say enough good things about the food, and even more so about the amazing couple running the place. SUPPORT FAMILY BUSINESS!

Recently moved into the Port Credit area and discovered Pizza Nostra.

Best thin crust Pizza!

Tried a few others and was dissapointed.

The owners (brothers) take personal care in preparing eachand every Pizza. The toppings are fresh, the crust is perfect, no delivery available but the short drive is worth it every time.

Best Pizza in the gta! I have been going since they opened. The quality has never changed. My family enjoys the pies well worth the drive! The new frozen pizzas are amazing for those wondering they don't disappoint! I am looking forward to my next slice.