Silversmith Brewing Co.

Super average beer, definitely not worth the hype. Not worth it to have the food. We ordered pull pork sandwich, cheese dip and cheesesteak sandwich. Food are poorly done, sauce on sandwiches are starchy. Won’t recommend it to anyone.

Great burger. Different but decent poutine. And some fine beers on tap. The guy working behind the bar was authentically nice.

10/10 all the way around. Great food, great beer, great service, great atmosphere. Awesome little merch store, definitely recommend getting a pub glass to go for only 5 bucks with purchase of a beer

Avi (our server) was incredible. Top notch customer service. Mirepoix bistro recommended this brewery and I’m incredibly happy with my experience.

Wow. Just wow.

Been coming here off and on for 10 years always with too much time in between visits.

Awesome beer, friendly service, and an unreal chicken sandwich.

Black lager is amazing. I miss the Oyster Stout though. Please bring some more stouts to the menu, perhaps one that's a bit on the sweeter side from a flavour profile.

Silversmith came at the perfect timing for dinner. Don’t be tricked by the outdoor patio, make sure you make your way inside and request a table with the old church pews.
It’s set inside an 1890s church with the perfect blend of new brewery ambiance made by a rustic reclaimed barn beam bar blended with the original brick, high vaulted ceilings, and stained glass windows of the gothic church architecture.
We paired some delicious IPAs with some smash burgers … it did not disappoint. Highly recommend this stop on anyone’s way to Niagara on the Lake.

We made a special stop as the website and reviews and recommendations for this place were stellar.
It did not disappoint. The 20 years hazy was perfection, the burgers, I dont even have words for how incredible they are. The fries as well, I was speechless.
The service was great, the decor at atmosphere is second to none. You can sit inside all day and just bask in the history and design and how the original elements have been lovingly restored and kept in place.
Will definitely make the trip again

Had high hopes for this place. Appetizers were good. Drinks were good. My husband enjoyed his burger however the coleslaw was slipped on the bottom bun so it was extremely soggy. I had the chicken club and is was like it was pulled from the fryer and put right on the bun. It was so greasy I couldn’t even eat it. The Cajun fries were so overly salty I couldn’t touch those either. Our waiter once our food came out never once came to our table it was someone else. When I explained how the food was she just told me she would bring a container so I could take it home to someone else. Then we were still finishing our drinks it was like we were being rushed out the door. Not a cheap place to not enjoy it. Definitely a do not return for us!

This place is fantastic! We walked in and immediately greeted and found a table to sit. We ordered wine, cider. And beer. Had to have poutine and seasoned flatbread. Wow! This was our first poutine in Canada and we were impressed! The waiter, Avi, was absolutely spectacular. We asked about other places to visit and he was full of information! He was so knowledgeable and fun to chat with about other places, we wanted to bring him with us!

Went to Silversmith (church) on a Sunday, absolutely amazing staff. Amazing beer, highly recommend the Black Lager, and the Butcher Burger.

I absolutely loved the place. The beer was fantastic, the food was great and the waiters were all so nice. Thursday night has live music and, being an old church, it sounds amazing. The black lager well deserves its award.

MUST try the black lager! Noticeable coffee flavour that makes it so delicious. The fact that it's a restored church makes for a unique experience with a great atmosphere. Norcini, who makes the food is fantastic. Not a bad thing on the menu. Their crispy chicken club or buffalo chicken sandwich is so incredible it will have you coming back for more.

Beer was yummy! Service was good considering there was only 2 of them and the place was slammed. All came out really quick and was enjoyable!

Was in NOTL for a few days and we decided to stop in for a change of pace from all the wineries. So glad we did! Between the 4 of us we tried 5 different beers and they were all exceptional. I bought 12 to take home and have since tried 3 more. Unbelievably good beer, every single one of them!

We didn't eat there but the food looked amazing. Also, such a good vibe with amazing, friendly service.

Can't wait to visit again!

O. M. G. Food was so good, staff is very friendly and very good environment. Lots of cool merch. This one waiter that served me was so freindly, and nice, he had blonde buzz cut with a mustache.if you see him, make sure you thank him for all his work, you can really tell he loves his job. I definitely recommend if you're in the area.

I love it when a business can take over a cool old space and truly make it feel like it could have never been anything else. Loved the beer selection, and the service was excellent.

What an amazing brewery. The beer selection is great, and the food is delicious. I love the atmosphere and would highly recommend this small business. Plus, the staff is superb.

Really enjoyed their beers! They have a large variety so there's something for everyone. Really cool atmosphere and the staff was super friendly.

First Canadian brewery on our great lake tour. Enjoyable beer. Brewery is in an old church. Beer not brewed at this location. Ran into a couple from our area.